The Ways of Integrating Classroom Teaching of English with Online Learning

Zhang Lihui                    

Shanghai University of Finance and Economics

zhanglh@mail.shufe.edu.cn

August 8, 2003

Abstract: With the advent of online courses and distance education technology, it is necessary to carefully consider how the use of this technology fosters classroom teaching in adult education programs. This paper has outlined the classroom teaching and online learning characteristics and suggested some ways to integrate classroom teaching with online learning through course development and more interactivity based on web technology. These ways have found the support from constructivist learning theory because the latter allows both learners and facilitators to take advantage of the World Wide Web, and focuses on making connections and making meaning in the learning process.

Key words: integration, classroom teaching, online learning, constructionist

 

    With internet changing our everyday life so profoundly, higher education is also experiencing great changes in its teaching ideology and modes. Traditional teaching modes are faced with challenges from open learning channels either through TV, VCD, DVD or internet. In this case, it is of great significance for us to explore the ways of integrating classroom teaching with online learning.

    Unlike other subjects such as geography, history, economics and the forth, which can be taught online completely to some degree, language teaching, as a subject based on communications, has more demand for the students’ presence and intercourses with the teachers. It needs dialogues, responses, speeches and other presentation ways, therefore, classroom teaching can never be fully replaced by internet or online education. What interested me when I was searching internet for information on classroom teaching and online learning in Chinese was that of 17,600 items about the theme I found only 3 or 4 were about classroom teaching of English and online learning. Most of them were about other subjects. Then I tried English websites of this subject and what I found has not excited me more because of 172,000 items most are about MBA and other courses of degree education. The fact reveals that language teaching will hold its front line in the classrooms no matter how far online learning can go. In this sense, I started to think about what English teachers can do in the classroom in the context of vast ocean of online learning information and how more interactivity can be organized vividly online.

 

Classroom Teaching of English and Its Characteristics

1. the importance of classroom teaching in English learning

    When one has no chance to visit a foreign country whose language he ‘s learning, classroom teaching has been the dominant channel in his language learning. There are three reasons for this: (1) Historically, all formal education has been expected to take place in a class where a teacher is  a knowledge giver, a lecturer and an instructor. Only in the classroom can one feel his education is valuable and acknowledged. This is traditional understanding of education. (2) Since language is used to communicate, that is, to speak and write in, it requests more practice in dialogues and speeches. Therefore, imitation and responses are very important for the language learners. (3) One’s learning process is not only satisfied with the knowledge acquisition through physical and mental activities but also with the intercourses with others in which one can experience different emotions and therefore get more recognition about himself. The emotional and psychological experiences in communication with others are equally important for English learners. This personal aspect makes language learning process quite different from what one experiences in self-teaching through TV courses, correspondence courses, VCD, DVD or online courses. So compared with other subjects, classroom teaching of English (and the same with all other languages) has the following characteristics:

(1)Responsiveness:  The English learner needs to acquire his English skills through his constant reactions to the teachers and his fellow students. He himself is a source of responses and also an object of responses.

(2)Simultaneousness: The English learner needs to make sentences or patterns simultaneously, that is, he needs to draw different words from his reservoir of English to form the sentences right for the occasions he’s on. The uncertainty and simultaneousness are important fun source or pain source for the English learner.

(3)Personality: People are different from other animals because we’re able to express our feelings in language and the language can be very complicated, systematic and delicate. This is human communication. Classroom teaching has provided vivid circumstances under which learners can learn to vent their feelings very emotionally, which can’t be found in other ways of learning.

    The three characteristics have determined that classroom teaching in English learning plays a vital role in one’s learning process. However, the role has been defined differently at the information age.

2 the new role of English classroom teaching

Traditionally, English learners have obtained English knowledge in the classrooms under the guidance of teachers who chiefly build their teaching on textbooks, movies, VCRs, recorders. Teachers and the textbooks are the most important information sources. The learners don’t have other channels to learn English except the two sources. Even though the teachers can play movies or VCRs or tapes to the students, the materials are often very focused and limited. Teachers are chief instructors and knowledge implementer.

At the information age, people’s access to English materials is unbelievably convenient. (1) Through cable TV, one can watch CNN, BBC, HBO, ABC, etc, and the information in these programs is newer and closer to the language native speakers’ life. (2) Through local TV English programs, for instance, CCTV9, IBS, one can get information about what’s happening at home and abroad in English. (3) Through internet, all English electronic newspapers are accessible. What’s more, the advanced IT technology has made it possible for one to watch, read and listen to news or other materials in English online! If he is interested in Shakespeare, he can just turn to www.goole.com or www.yahoo.com or www.hotbot.com or any other search engines and within seconds thousands of millions of information items about Shakespeare appear. What the learner can do is browse them as quickly as possible.

The variety of English acquisition channels has changed the role of classroom teaching. Since classroom is no longer the only place one can get knowledge, teachers have to consider how to integrate IT into classroom teaching or devise more activities based on internet. They have to change from traditional classroom instructors to organizers of classroom and online discussions and assignments, supervisors and guides of the students’ internet searching and reading, collaborators of the students who are eager to teach themselves through internet. In a word, classroom teaching today, at most, is one very important channel but not the only channel anymore in one’s learning process.

 

Online Learning of English and Its Characteristics

    Fewer English learners of other generations can be luckier than people today. In the past when internet was still the physicists’ mystical field, people could only resort to limited textbooks, VCRs and recordings. As a result, the students couldn’t immediately adapt themselves to the working positions once they entered a company. Today. the story is different. According to some statistics, 95% of the internet materials are expressed in English. The economic strength of English speaking countries like the US and the UK, has even reinforced the influence of English. There have never been better conditions and easier access for English learners. So long as one has a computer connected to internet, he can always teach himself anywhere and anytime. This is the emergence of the online learning.

1. Online learning and its techonology

Online education refers to any form of learning/teaching that takes place via a computer network. The network could be a local bulletin board system (BBS) or it could be the global internet and world wide web. The network could also be a local area network (LAN) or an intranet within a particular organization. Historically, online interaction has been called "computer mediated communication" (CMC), although this term covers applications beyond instruction (e.g., decision-making in work teams).

The most common function used in online education is electronic mail (email) that allows students and teachers to send messages to each other. In addition, most networks also provide conferencing capabilities that let participants conduct multi-person discussions either in real-time (often called "chats") or on a delayed basis (asynchronous). There are also more elaborate systems called MUD/MOOs for group interaction as well as many "groupware" programs. The latter often involve simultaneous viewing of graphics (slides) and use of a shared writing space (i.e., electronic whiteboard). Online education also involves access to databases in the form of text files or multimedia web pages, as well as the exchange of information (e.g., assignments, course materials) via file transfers.

It is not my purpose to describe the various capabilities of networks or different types of CMC systems, but to focus on the instructional aspects of online interaction. There are many good books that discuss these aspects and you should consult them for such details (see Bibliography) . To read about the latest research on this subject, see the International Journal of Educational Telecommunications (published by AACE ), THE Journal , or Educational Technology magazine. The publications of the ACM and the IEEE provide good background on the computing technologies involved.

In most cases, online instruction takes place in the context of distance education, i.e., settings in which learners and teachers are located in different places and all or most interaction takes place via the network.

2. Nature of Online Learning/Teaching

   The rapid development of internet technology has granted the online learning the following characteristics:

(1)Easy accessibility. All information is accessed very fast and conveniently. For example, if we want to learn about Milton, we type a word in some search engine and immediately we get millions of items about Milton. We can find his picture, his story and his works. Before the Web was used, people needed to visit libraries again and again to seek some information about him. The following graph is a vivid illustration of the internet’s influence on human beings’ information gathering. Before the web’s being used, people spent most of their time searching information, as a result, the time for analyzing the information was reduced. After the web was introduced, people are able to spend much less time gathering equal if not larger amount of information and thus get more time to analyze the information which is conducive to foster creative and unique ideas.


 

(before web’s being used)

 

 

(after webs introduction)

  


(2) Openness. Since all materials online are accessible, they are open to everyone. CMC also changes the social dynamics of education -- putting everyone (students and teachers) on equal footing. Under usual circumstances, everyone can post messages, so each online participant has the same opportunity to contribute ideas or comments. Consider the situation of the WWW; a web page or site created by a high school student has exactly the same accessiblity as one created by a Nobel laureate. Similarly, anyone on the internet or a BBS can send a message to anyone else, regardless of who they are.

One of the important implications of this change in the status quo is that the teacher or expert does not automatically command a presence in an online environment. There is no counterpart to standing at the front of the classroom pontificating to a captured audience until the bell rings! Any teacher or expert who tries to "lecture" to an online group will quickly have them tuning out and doing other things (like sending messages to each other or forming their own discussion groups). In online education, the instructor must adopt a role as facilitator or moderator -- someone who encourages participation and keeps discussions focused on certain topics. As it turns out this is a much more difficult task than conventional classroom teaching which basically involves presentation of material.

(3) Higher demand for English reading and writing skills. Learning and teaching online is much different than a traditional classroom experience (even when used as part of a conventional class). Since most communication takes place via written messages (or files), writing skill and the ability to put thoughts into words are paramount. People who have poor writing skills may be at a disadvantage in an online environment. On the other hand, having to write everything gives people a chance to think about their responses, especially in an asynchronous setting, where you do not need to respond immediately. Furthermore, one of the side effects of any class involving CMC is plenty of practice writing, often resulting in improved communication skills. For many learners, this outcome is just as important as the subject matter being learned.

 

The Ways of Integrating Classroom Teaching of English with Online Learning

  In order to create the best effect of education in the context of information explosion, we need to consider how to make the most of the online materials in the classroom teaching and produce a vivid virtual classroom online. Now that many books and papers have discussed how to apply multi-media in the classroom teaching, my purpose here is not to explore what technology can be used in the classrooms. My interest is how to develop some English courses based on internet materials and integrate them into the conventional classroom teaching and then I try to explore some interactivity between teachers and students virtually supported by the constructionist learning theory.

1. Courses based on internet materials

    As we all know, English teaching has seen more than 50 years on mainland China and some English textbooks have been published such as College English, 21 Century College English, New Course English, Active English Series, etc. These books have played so important a role in pushing Chinese college students’ English level that their publication has become very lucrative business. However, with any set of English books, we always hear complaints from the students who seem to be increasingly demanding. The chief complaints are about the lack of timeliness and practicability of the selected materials. Some articles are so outdated that the students feel the books are not authoritative at all. On the other hand, some materials are disconnected with the situations the students are living in. As a result, the students feel they are learning something far away from their life and when they graduate and enter some company to start their work, they find what they have learned in school cannot be used at all. The situation confuses the students as well as the English educators. Besides, some foreign experts are also confused about the English textbooks widely used in the colleges. They wonder why some materials are so outdated and inapplicable. The following are some courses which I think can be based on internet materials.

 

Courses

Advantages

Methods

A Survey of English Speaking Countries

l        Data are very updated.

l        Ample graphics and introduction enables students to understand the object place, event or figures better.

l        Some anecdotes can enhance students’ interest in English.

l        The teacher outlines the websites about some particular country and ask students to read before classes.

l        The teacher organizes the discussions or presentations based on the online materials.

l        The teacher devises some questions or tests for the students to finish after classes.

Newspaper English Readings

l        News and reports are updated and dynamic.

l        Styles are varied.

l        The teacher lists the websites of some world famous newspapers in the English speaking countries and ask the students to read before classes.

l        The teacher leads the students to analyse the layout of a newspaper and then give instructions into each column. The computer lab is needed for the class.

l        The students learn to establish their own newspaper website under the guidance of the teacher.

British and American Literature

l        Texts are accessible.

l        Background knowledge and relevant reviews can be easily found.

l        Students can form their own opinions from reading different reviews.

l        The teacher asks the students to pick up some topics either on stories, novels, essays, poetry or drama and then do tremendous searching online

l        After their exploration, the students are asked to give very detailed presentations to the class. It would be best for the students to apply advanced technology in their presentations.

Writing Skills

l        .Ample information is accessible

l        In word, there are many templates for business English writing. Students are encouraged to explore them to get the knowledge about the writing skills.

l        Online there are many good writings of different styles, the teacher should list some websites for students to explore themselves under the guidance of the teacher.

l        Some leading universities attach their writing syllabi online and the English teacher can learn a lot from them

International Political Relations

l        Data are very updated.

l        Ample graphics and introduction enables students to understand the object place, event or figures better.

l        Some anecdotes can enhance students’ interest in English.

l        The teacher outlines the websites about some particular country and ask students to read before classes.

l        The teacher organizes the discussions or presentations based on the online materials.

l        The teacher devises some questions or tests for the students to finish after classes.

Western Culture

l        Data are very updated.

l        Ample graphics and introduction enables students to understand the object place, event or figures better.

l        Some anecdotes can enhance students’ interest in English.

l        The teacher outlines the websites about some particular country and ask students to read before classes.

l        The teacher organizes the discussions or presentations based on the online materials.

l        The teacher devises some questions or tests for the students to finish after classes.

 

    Obviously, the listed courses here are usually intended for the English learners who have already had adequate ability in English reading and writing. As for those English beginners, the courses based on internet materials may be too difficult. In this case, they must receive instructions from their teachers in the classroom.

2. Creation of a rich virtual learning environment

     Since online learning is easier and more convenient for modern people, it will develop even more greatly in the near future. However, the significance of online learning is more than some technological convenience. It helps to encourage people to learn more actively, deeply and individually.

  According to modern constructivists, learning should be a process of opening oneself constantly to experiences because "learners actively construct and reconstruct knowledge out of their experiences in the world" (Kafai and Resnik, 1996, p. 3). Learners create their own knowledge by how they put their worlds together.  Their experiences in learning shape their understanding and help them to make meaning from new information in light of their personal experiences and thus, outcomes are often unexpected, unique and individual. The theory has defined modern learning very differently. Learning is doing. Learning is individual. Learning is a life course. Within the theory, three elements should be taken into consideration when trying to provide a good learning environment for learners: choice, diversity, and congeniality.  The learner is the best person to decide what is to be personally meaningful.  If learners are empowered to choose what to construct or create, they are more likely to be personally engaged and invested in the activity. Because learners have different skill levels and learning styles, a rich learning environment should encourage multiple learning styles and multiple representations of knowledge (Kafai & Resnik, 1996).  Having a congenial learning environment free from constraints of time and space is central for creating and sharing knowledge.  Creativity and interactivity among learners are best assimilated in a friendly and welcoming environment.

These ideas of constructivist learning theory can be applied in the on-line environment by providing opportunities for learners to engage in creative and collaborative activities that encourage knowledge construction. Thus, it should be a guiding principle in designing online activities.

2.1 Online Instructional Design Process

  In order to create the on-line environment focused on adult learners' construction of knowledge, instructional design and teaching strategies are considered.
    The use of an instructional design process links constructivist learning theory to the practice of adult education.  Merrill (as cited in Duffy & Jonassen, 1992) suggests that instructional design and delivery systems are composed of two primary subsystems: a knowledge base and a family of instructional transaction shells.  "The knowledge base is a representation of all of the knowledge and skills to be taught.  Transaction shells enable the learners to interact with this knowledge in ways that best enable them to build appropriate mental models" (p. 109).  The World Wide Web has turned into one of the most accessible learning devices for creating an environment for constructing knowledge.  It provides patterns of learner interactions that enable the learner to create new relationships with knowledge and new representations of knowledge.  These instructional transaction shells provide learners with the means necessary to understand different content topics and solve problems.
    Designing web-based environments for learning and communicating is more than just placing information on the web, it requires new skills to produce web sites and to communicate with learners.  These skills include audience consideration, web design process, self-directed learning techniques, two-way feedback mechanisms, navigational science for directional and psychological movement, expertise in content and content architecture, links and relationships management, mind map development, and learning theory and human development  (Morris and Hinrichs, 1996).  It is important to consider the learner's needs, differences between novice and expert users, diverse platforms and browsers, graphics capability, and Internet providers.
        Creating a web page for instruction involves the process of analysis, design, development, testing, implementation, and updating.  It is during the analysis process that the identification of users and tasks the web site will perform are determined.  During the design process, major high-level topics and sets of information are divided into subgroups and a theme is selected.  An important feature of the design process is the brainstorming of the relationship between the sets of information and subgroups and how they support the theme.  Identification of the document structure constitutes a component of the development stage.  Throughout the testing phase, all linkages should be tested by novices and experts.  The last phase of the design process is the implementation and updating of the web site, which includes the insertion of feedback tools on the site, the transfer of files into the World Wide Web, and the frequent verification for broken links (Morris & Hinrichs, 1996).
         Certain aspects related to course content should be considered.  For example, syllabi, handouts, and class assignments provide guidelines for students to follow and give learners a sense of place and structure on the web.  The text structure must follow the use of command verbs to cue learners what to do next; short lines and short paragraphs create exciting visual stimulation for learners.  Recommendations related to text formatting included the need to use brief text, active voice, bullets to format a list, whitespace, left-justify, etc.  The language style should be conversational as if the web site would be speaking to the learner. Bullets, headlines and pull quotes should be combined with paragraphs or explanatory text after the bullet heading.  When inserting links, the identification of  patterns in the links and a brief description of the link should help learners navigate through the course more efficiently.  The use of templates is an option that can help organize the information structure.  Having a common navigational control bar for all pages can assist the user to easily reach locations on the web site (Morris & Hinrichs, 1996).  In order to integrate human mind maps with web mind maps to create an environment for helping learners' construct knowledge, the web site must have a set of common features, it must identify with the learner, and provide interactive tools.  These features follow the visual representation of conceptual meanings.
        The role of the instructional designer is to move from structuring teaching strategies to designing environments in which constructivist learning can take place.  Duffy & Bednar (as cited in Duffy & Jonassen, 1992) suggest that these environments present 's rich contexts, authentic tasks, collaboration for the development and evaluation of multiple perspectives, an abundance of tools to enhance communication and access to real-world examples and problems, reflective thinking, modeling or problem solving by experts in the content domain, and apprenticeship mentoring relationships to guide learning" (p. 132).

2.2  Online Teaching Strategies

Since online learning is chiefly developed to offer adults continuing education with the purpose of decreasing travel time for learners and increasing communication between students and faculty, it is very important for the learning strategies capable of fostering student and faculty communication, individualizing the learning to the student's needs, and supporting and nourishing learners' construction of knowledge. As a result, instruction. . . "should not focus on transmitting plans to the learner, but rather in developing skills of the learner to construct (and reconstruct) plans in response to situational demands and opportunities"  (Duffy and Jonanssen, 1992, p. 4).  To facilitate the constructivist learning approach in an on-line environment two examples will be highlighted: concept maps and on-line discussions with group reflection (also known as mailing list or listserv).
     Concept Maps. "A concept map is a schematic device for representing a set of concept meanings embedded in a framework of propositions" (Novak and Gowin, 1984, p. 15).  Concept maps (Novak, 1998) are a visual representation of conceptual meanings used to develop shared meaning between learner and facilitator or between learners in a group.  Concept maps are a metacognitive tool that demonstrates explicit, overt representation of concepts and propositions a person holds, they allow teachers and learners to exchange views on why a particular propositional linkage is good or valid, or to recognize missing linkages between concepts that suggest a need for new learning" (Novak and Gowin, 1984, p. 19).
        In the on-line learning project, concept maps were used in two different ways.  First, students were asked to read two different books discussing the topic of the course.  A concept map was developed that represented the similarities and differences between the two books.  Students then used the maps as a format for on-line discussion of their understanding of the readings. Second, students were asked to view popular films that dealt with the course topic.  After viewing the film, the student created a concept map that depicted what was seen in the film and how that related to the theories under study.  The maps were then used as a basis for the on-line case discussions of the films and their connections to the course topics.   Concept maps were created electronically with a software program called Inspiration.  Once the maps were created the students could share, discuss, alter or revise their maps as their learning and understanding of the concepts under study grew and changed.
    On-line Discussion with Group Reflection. In this project, on-line discussion groups were established and were included as part of the course requirements.  Learners were expected to participate and the instructor initially established discussion questions related to the concepts under study. The discussion questions served the purpose of initiating the on-line activities, but it soon became apparent that the learners would take the discussion in the direction that enhanced their learning the most.  On-line discussions were used to discuss course concepts, case studies, and course readings.  It was interesting that the on-line discussion seemed to promote a more in-depth level of analysis and synthesis.  The learners’ discussion points and comments were a thoughtful analysis and critique, of not only their course work, but their life experiences as well.  Learners reported that they used a constructivist process in preparing for and participating in the on-line discussion.  The learner would read the discussion questions, review some of the material in the text, read and think about the contributions of other students and then frame their response.  Responses were thoughtfully created and showed many connections to other course work and learning materials.

2.3 Online teaching methods

The single most important element of successful online education is interaction among participants. It is the instructor's role as a facilitator to ensure that a high level of interaction occurs in an online course. This can be achieved in many ways.

(1) The simplest technique is to have students complete regular (e.g., weekly) assignments which consist of answers to problems or questions posed by the instructor. If these responses are posted publicly so that everyone in the class can read them, this provides a basis for sharing of ideas and discussion among participants. And, sharing of ideas is one of the most powerful aspects of online education.

(2) An even more powerful form of interaction is group activity. Students can be divided into small groups of 3-4 based upon common or complementary interests/skills. These groups can be formed for the full duration of a course (e.g., design teams for a project) or they can be short-term for the completion of a particular assignment (e.g., weekly discussion of a problem/issue). Group membership can be assigned by the instructor or can be determined by the participants themselves. For example in some of our courses, we require students to work in online teams but we leave it up to them to determine who they want to work with (based upon background information posted by each participant beforehand). There are also a whole collection of "groupware" programs that allow more sophisticated group interaction (such as shared workspaces and decision-making tools) which can be employed in courses.

(3) Getting feedback on things posted is very important to most people. In fact if participants do not receive feedback on their responses, they will eventually stop posting messages. Providing feedback is the primary responsibility of the instructor (or teaching assistants/tutors). Every major assignment completed online should entail some kind of feedback comments (even if they are very brief). With large groups, the instructor may have to provide group rather than individual feedback, i.e., summarize responses in one message to all participants. Another way to handle feedback is to use peer evaluation, i.e., have participants critique and comment on each other's work. This works particularly well if students are paired up and take turns evaluating each other's work over a series of assignments.

(4) One of the intriguing aspects of online education is that it can sometimes succeed in spite of an ineffective instructor. If students form their own discussion groups or project teams using the email/conferencing capabilities of the system, there can be a high level of interaction regardless of what the instructor does/doesn't do. It is also possible for students to upload or exchange files (or web site addresses) so that useful information can be shared among participants. Online education is inherently student-centered and with a group of highly-motivated students, it can be a very powerful form of learning that is relatively immune to the quality of teaching. On the other hand, a good teacher who facilitates well and ensures lots of feedback can make an online class much more worthwhile and enjoyable for participants. Futhermore, online group activities take a lot of effort to organize and manage -- a task that should be performed by the instructor.

 

Final Thoughts

Computer networks are evolving rapidly and hence the world of online education is constantly changing. For example, in the past, CMC has been pretty well restricted to text messages, emphasizing writing skills. But it is now possible to have two-way video conversations over the internet (using a program such as CUSeeMe) and the web makes it possible to include audio or video clips in a document. So, written responses will become less important over time and people will increasingly interact online using all their sensory modalities.

The increasing number of online options and features is beginning to make it difficult for instructors and course designers to determine which functions should be used for what aspects of a course. For example, what is the best use of synchronous (real-time chats or MUD/MOOs) versus asynchronous conferencing (forums, listservs) for a given class? When is an audio/video link needed, or a slide-sharing/whiteboard feature? Because there are so many programs available now for CMC; it is difficult to evaluate them and decide which one(s) to use. Of course, over time personal experience and research studies will provide guidance but at present the technology is evolving too quickly for there to be much of either.

The changes in the social dynamic of the classroom brought about by online education are pretty profound. Online classes emphasize social interaction among the participants and nullify the authoritarian role of the teacher or subject matter expert. People need to get used to working in online teams/groups. Teachers must get used to fulfilling the role of facilitator/moderator in which they have to cultivate both personal and group participation. And assessment techniques need to move away from testing to projects, assignments, and case studies.

Everyone who experiences online education realizes that this is the beginning of a new paradigm for learning and teaching. Welcome to the 21st century! And enjoy your journeys along the information highway.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

References

 

 Duffy, T. & Jonassen, D.  (1992).  Constructivism and the technology of instruction:  A conversation.  Hillsdale, New Jersey:  Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Kafai, Y, .& Resnik, M.  (1996).  Constructionism in practice: Designing, thinking, and learning in a digital world.  Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associations.
Inspiration Software, Inc. [on-line]. 
Available at http://www.inspiration.com/
Lambert, L., et al.
(1995).  The constructivist leader.  New York: Teachers College Press.
Morris, M., & Hinrichs, R.  (1996).  Web page design.  Mountain View, CA: SunSoft Press.
Novak, J. & Gowin, B.  (1984).  Learning how to learn.  Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Novak, J.  (1998).  Learning, Creating and using knowledge:  Concept maps as tools to understand and facilitate the process in schools and corporations.  New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum Assoc.
http://home.sprynet.com/~gkearsley/online.htm

 http://www.bsu.edu/teachers/departments/edld/conf/constructionism.html

http://www.collegeboard.com/press/html0102/html/bollinger.html

 http://www.mstu.edu/~itconf/proceed02/14.html